8 am: 51°FPartly Sunny

10 am: 62°FMostly Sunny

12 pm: 70°FSunny

2 pm: 72°FSunny

More Weather

Prison and jail claims costing state millions

Jun. 25, 2013 @ 12:00 AM

CHARLESTON -- West Virginia spent nearly $12 million over the last decade in court costs, lawyer fees and settlement monies for sexual misconduct claims at prisons and regional jails.

The state paid out $5.1 million to prisoners and their lawyers in settlements and fees from Jan. 1, 2003, and June 1, 2013, according to the state Board of Risk and Insurance Management (BRIM).

The state spent an additional $6.6 million to defend sexual misconduct cases over the last decade, using the money to pay its own lawyers, expert witnesses, special investigators and court fees.

While many claimants did not receive any money, a handful received hundreds of thousands of dollars from BRIM. The state paid $2 million for a claim filed in Sept. 1, 2007.

The average settlement, however, was about $20,000.

The Daily Mail obtained financial information about the cases through a Freedom of Information Act request to BRIM earlier this month.

In many cases, the state spent much more money defending itself against sexual misconduct claims than it paid out in settlements.

The state Department of Corrections and the Regional Jail Authority spent at least $10,000 in defense fees and court costs on almost every case, according to BRIM data.

The average case cost about $26,000, but some were far more costly.

Joe Delong, executive director of the state Regional Jails Authority, said he is not sure the jump in cases reflects any pattern or trend.

"We still have too many of them. And we still have too many of them that have a basis of merit as well," he said.

Delong said "better than 90 percent" of claims were by female inmates against male officers. And he said most of the female inmates who file claims have been sentenced by the state, and were in jail awaiting beds in the state's overcrowded prison system.

There were far more alleged cases at state jails than prisons. From 2003 to 2013, there were 97 claims filed against the Department of Corrections. There were 157 claims filed against the Regional Jail Authority during that time.

Delong said one reason for that disparity is the number of corrections personnel at the facilities. There are around 2,000 correctional officers in state prisons, watching over 5,400 inmates.

In the jails, there are about 900 officers for 4,900 inmates. Delong said in some cases there is only one officer for 100 prisoners.

"They're fairly comparable in the number of inmates they have to house, but the RJA does it with half the staff. You're really comparing apples to oranges, to some degree," he said.

Delong attributes the recent drop in sexual misconduct claims to extra safety measures put in place by the regional jails.

There are about 260 female inmates in the regional jails awaiting a spot at Lakin Correctional Center, where the state houses all of its female offenders. There are about 450 inmates at Lakin.

The authority recently moved all female inmates awaiting placement in Lakin to Tygart Valley Regional Jail in Randolph County.

The jail system then installed surveillance cameras in all corridors and sections of Tygart Valley. Inmates and correctional officers can now be seen at all times.

Regional jails also are implementing regulations from the federal Prison Rape Elimination Act, which includes a confidential reporting system from inmates, and have rearranged its staffing patterns to hire more guards for less money. Corrections officers receive regular training.

"I think we're getting much, much better in creating a more safe and secure environment," Delong said.

The state's Lawyer Disciplinary Board filed charges against Huntington lawyer Kerry Nessel on May 13, alleging he brought frivolous lawsuits against the state Division of Corrections and solicited business from inmates at Lakin Correction Center.

Nessel, who will appear at a hearing before the board in October, is accused of recruiting inmates who had claimed they were sexually abused and offering them a cut of settlement monies for referring other inmates to him. Nessel has denied these allegations.



The Herald-Dispatch welcomes your comments on this article, but please be civil. Avoid profanity, obscenity, personal attacks, accusations of criminal activity, name-calling or insults to the other posters. Herald-dispatch.com does not control or monitor comments as they are posted, but if you find a comment offensive or uncivil, hover your mouse over the comment and click the X that appears in the upper right of the comment. If you do not want your comment to post to your personal Facebook page, uncheck the box below the comment.